At least 5 injured in stabbing attack at rabbi’s home in New York

A man entered Rabbi Rottenburg’s Shul in Monterey, New York during a Hanukkah celebration Saturday night and set about him with a machete, before fleeing in a vehicle. Five people were taken to hospitals with stab wounds, two of whom were in critical condition, according to the Orthodox Jewish Public Affairs Council for the Hudson Valley region. The organization said one of the victims had been stabbed six times. The assailant was later arrested and charged with harassment and committing a hate crime. The attack came after at least seven other anti-Semitic incidents were reported in New York City this week, prompting the New York City Police Department to increase the number of officers in predominantly Jewish areas. The stabbings also came less than a month after four people were killed in a targeted shooting at a Jersey City kosher supermarket prompted by “hatred of the Jewish people.”

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

32 thoughts on “ At least 5 injured in stabbing attack at rabbi’s home in New York

  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 8:20 at 8:20
    Permalink

    Another, Stain of Insanity in a continued March of Hate within Human History. One would think what is known about the Remarkable Jewish Culture would be Welcomed & No Longer be a Burden of Ignorance still in Existence?

    Reply
    • Dec 29, 2019 @ 10:09 at 10:09
      Permalink

      YOU ARE RIGHT; HOWEVER WE JEWS ARE FULL OF HATE TOWARDS ANYONE WHO IS NOT JEWISH!
      WE ARE A HATEFULL SHARMOUTAS.

      Reply
      • Dec 29, 2019 @ 15:01 at 15:01
        Permalink

        With a last name like “Carrol” you are NOT Jewish at all. I know Jews all my life and can tell you they DO NOT have HATE for ANYONE. The Jews problem is many are self-hating Jews (Look at J-Street who hate Israel). Many do not believe in GOd because of what you “Good” Christians did to Jews in WWII. FDR turned away European Jews from coming to the US and one of the religious leadership that asked him NOT to let the JEws into the US was the leader of the Reformed Movement. How do you like that one. So Jim Carrol why don’t you answer that one.

        Reply
      • Dec 29, 2019 @ 16:18 at 16:18
        Permalink

        @Jcarrol… Jewish Culture has a Long History of Promoting & Defending other People, Cultures & those under Slavery as well. It is Enlighten Culture of Equality for Those that Follow a Rule of Law for All!

        Reply
      • Dec 29, 2019 @ 18:17 at 18:17
        Permalink

        Liar and anti-semite. Jews do not hate non Jews. You fool no one with your comments.

        Reply
      • Dec 29, 2019 @ 19:41 at 19:41
        Permalink

        Jim Carrol you are projecting your hate onto Jews and other groups always mentioning sharmoutas, usually including the words hairy and humpbacked. Please look at yourself in a mirror and honestly understand that you could benefit from psychiatric counselling. I am a mental health professional and am making this suggestion because you may help yourself relieve some of your rage.

        Reply
    • Dec 29, 2019 @ 15:44 at 15:44
      Permalink

      the criminal is a black muslim, he is in custody

      Reply
      • Dec 29, 2019 @ 18:40 at 18:40
        Permalink

        TYPICAL SCHVARTZE…TIME FOR JEWS TO START RESPONDING!

        Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 9:06 at 9:06
    Permalink

    All fake tommies are antisemitic pigs.

    Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 9:49 at 9:49
    Permalink

    Words are useless / cheap.
    Get yourself guns + shomrim + fight like true Jews. If attacked – shoot to kill.
    Finally : its time to come home
    where a mighty IDF will deal with
    all those medieval / insane Jew haters!

    Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 10:05 at 10:05
    Permalink

    I KNOW THAT WE JEWS ARE COWARDS BUT NOT THAT MUCH!
    IF THEY RESISTED THIS WOULDN’T HAPPEN!
    COWERED SHARMOUTA JEWS ARE EVERYWHERE NOW.

    Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 10:16 at 10:16
    Permalink

    I HOPE HE STABBED CHRISTIANS OR MUSLIMS INSTEAD OF JEWS.
    I HOPE ALL HUMANITY WILL BE WIPED OUT EXCEPT THE CHOSEN PEOPLE OF GOD ” JEWS”.

    Reply
    • Dec 29, 2019 @ 15:33 at 15:33
      Permalink

      I hope you die of cancer of pain pig jim sharmoutaAMEN SELA

      Reply
    • Dec 29, 2019 @ 15:58 at 15:58
      Permalink

      FAKE JIM IT SHOULD BE YOU AND YOUR WORTHLESS FAMILY NEXT!

      Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 11:08 at 11:08
    Permalink

    ★  I am making $98/hour telecommuting. I never imagined that it was honest to goodness yet my closest companion is acquiring $20 thousand a month by working on the web, that was truly shocking for me, she prescribed me to attempt it. simply give it a shot on the accompanying site.. go to home media tech tab for more detail reinforce your heart…… Read more

    Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 12:33 at 12:33
    Permalink

    orthodox Jews have t wake up / step out of their ivory tower and deal with todays reality !
    Meaning : dont behave like dumb sheep by ignoring the threat of
    attacks by Jew – haters ! Arm yourself / get yourself guards, then fight + kill those who want to kill you!
    Meaning: learn from history ! Check what happend in europe when hitler was at work there – then learn the lessons by coming home to Israel, your home !
    The israeli army + police is present/able + ready to kill those who want to kill the Jews !
    In the diaspora you are left alone / sitting ducks / sheep waiting for the butcher !
    Wake up + come home NOW before its too late!

    Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 13:55 at 13:55
    Permalink

    If i would be a Jew I could live everywhere in the west but not in the mideast. There are Problems and hate crimes but everything is better than mideast. Mideast will be doomed and many Folks will die. Israel has no future in the mideast. It s the last Resort. Why idiots started up a jewish Country in the mideast is for me the most irrational Thing. It will not end in good. No nukes and anything else can Change that strategic mistake from beginning

    Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 14:51 at 14:51
    Permalink

    A horrible crime, especially attacking people at a religious gathering. The world is truly a messed up place when people behave like savages and use machetes. Its the type of thing you’d expect to happen in places like South Africa not New York. At least so far no one has died. I agree with the above comments to be armed. Concealed carry restrictions are not helping, if everyone had a pistol and knew how to use it these types of attacks won’t happen. Few people are willing to go in knowing that they will die and those that are will will do it anyway.
    So be armed and a lot less people will be hurt.

    Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 16:20 at 16:20
    Permalink

    Taught Hate Causes Hateful Actions!

    Reply
    • Dec 29, 2019 @ 17:01 at 17:01
      Permalink

      The only way to change people’s minds on matters is free speech. Complete and unhindered debate washes away false information, unfortunatly thats no longer the society that we live in. The more this antisemitic drumbeat continues the more discussion will move into closed groups due to the media, bigtech and other political taboos. The result is no one trusts the media, most people believe that we are been lied to. So these groups reinforce each others beliefs and bad this happen. If debate was encouraged and open then we would throw it all into the same pot and it will sort its self out in time.

      So welcome to the new world, throw in a lot of Muslim immigration, Israeli expansion, no open and free debate and we have this. The odd thing with this stabbing was as far as i can tell there was not the usual Israeli trigger. By that i mean when you guys do harmful things it triggers people around the world. That is one of the reasons why we have such a growing movement against Israel and many innocent Jews unfairly and unfortunately suffer.

      Reply
      • Dec 29, 2019 @ 17:47 at 17:47
        Permalink

        It would be better if when Israel spoke they did not make out like they represent Jews Worldwide. Speak for Israel and Israeli Jews but leave us alone, its not fair to try to use us as shields for your political and military actions. Its why whenever you do something that draws condemnation there us a large spike in anti jew behavior worldwide.

        Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 17:30 at 17:30
    Permalink

    I get paid over $98 per hour working from home with 2 kids at home. I just got paid $ 8460 in my mpreviousonth It Sounds unbelievable but you wont forgive yourself if you don’t check it….. Read more

    Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 18:42 at 18:42
    Permalink

    A NEW BERNIE GOETZ WILL BE COMING SOON. THICK-LIPPED SCHVARTZES BEWARE!

    Reply
  • Dec 29, 2019 @ 20:54 at 20:54
    Permalink

    Well Jim, I really hope that this does not escalate, people need to learn to sit down and discuss their issues. I dont know much about this Black Hebrew group but their members have been seemingly involved in two incidents in a relatively short period of time. So whats there issue, why are they all of a sudden attacking Jews.

    It all makes little sense to me, so hopefully someone writes a nice article explaining this because people need a reason to go postal and two attacks in such a short period is too continental.

    Reply
  • Dec 30, 2019 @ 4:50 at 4:50
    Permalink

    The true Jews are rising up against the Ashkenazi fake Jews. The Black Hebrews are doing G’ds work and we should all be rejoicing and praising G-d that he has chosen this time and our nation to begin the healing and cleansing process that will usher in the New Dawn.

    Reply
  • Dec 30, 2019 @ 5:39 at 5:39
    Permalink

    Krav Maga is a lethal martial art invented to prevent this exact thing from happening in the first place.

    Reply
  • Dec 30, 2019 @ 7:01 at 7:01
    Permalink

    In America if you have a religion or Gay you qualify as a hate crime, If you are Jewish you qualify as domestic terrorism And it is all over the news. Statistics show that you are mot likely be killed by your spouse. Half of he US Military in the Mideast is protecting Israel. Bibi is going to build 2000 home on Palestinian land If Jews do not fell safe, Go to Israel it is much safer. Lucky you do not live in Chicago with 508 homicides so far this year. New York has had 249 homicides in the last 10 months. So Jews don’t take it personnel. I’ll make a suggestion, call your Senator to impeach Trump as long as he is office more and more American Jews will suffer

    Reply
    • Dec 30, 2019 @ 16:00 at 16:00
      Permalink

      The evidance for Israeli involvement in 9/11 is overwhelming, the Mossad credo of “By deception we shall make war” sums it all up. They wanted Iraq dealt with and the Middle East broken up and they largely succeeded in that. Its good to see that people are reading Veterans Today, its a great news site by ex-America intelligence staff.

      Reply
      • Dec 30, 2019 @ 16:57 at 16:57
        Permalink

        From what ive read the evidence is pretty convincing. If this was ever proven American Jews support for Israel would come to a permanent end overnight. American has kept Israel alive and to be stabbed in the back in this way would be devastating.

        Reply
  • Dec 30, 2019 @ 16:28 at 16:28
    Permalink

    Kristallnacht Holy Nacht may your lights burn bright forever

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Comments containing incitement, libel or offensive language are barred under DEBKAfile’s regulations

Your email address will not be published.

Font Resize
Contrast